Instead of relying on harsh scrubbing with a wash cloth or over-washing with your facial cleanser, reach for these kitchen staples: coconut oil, olive oil, or aloe vera (via Fine Feathered Heads). Coconut oil and its derivatives are already popular ingredients in store-bought and homemade makeup removers as it is wonderful at dissolving even stubborn makeup like waterproof mascara and kiss-proof lipstick. Just take a pea-sized amount, rub it between your hands to liquify it, and then rub gently over the makeup. Remove with warm (not hot) water and/or a super-soft cloth to reveal perfectly-clean skin. The great thing is, this is even a great option for those with oily skin, as oil cleansing with coconut oil actually helps dissolve excess oil and can hydrate skin properly to prevent excess oil production (via Wellness Mama).  

Olive oil can be used in a similar way; just take a few drops of the oil, work gently over your face, rinse/wipe off, and then follow with a gentle cleanser to remove excess oil (via Fine Feathered Heads). Aloe Vera is another excellent option for removing makeup, as it not only helps to dissolve and remove residues, but soothes the skin in the process. Simply add some aloe vera to either oil, and proceed as instructed above. This will both increase the effectiveness of the homemade remover and calm your skin.